Difference between revisions of "Fermilab-2019: Cosmology with CMB-S4"

From CMB-S4 wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Wednesday March 13th)
 
(87 intermediate revisions by 29 users not shown)
Line 10: Line 10:
 
[http://indico.fnal.gov/e/cmbs4collaboration2019 Official Workshop Website: Registration, Participants, Hotels, Logistics].
 
[http://indico.fnal.gov/e/cmbs4collaboration2019 Official Workshop Website: Registration, Participants, Hotels, Logistics].
  
'''Location: IARC Building at Fermilab''' http://iarc.fnal.gov/
+
'''Location: IARC Building at Fermilab''' http://iarc.fnal.gov/
  
'''Remote Connection Information: '''
+
'''Remote Connection Information:     '''
  
 
'''Zoom link: https://fnal.zoom.us/j/356003665'''
 
'''Zoom link: https://fnal.zoom.us/j/356003665'''
Line 36: Line 36:
  
 
== Agenda ==
 
== Agenda ==
 
Note: No breakfast!
 
  
 
=== Wednesday March 13th ===
 
=== Wednesday March 13th ===
  
Morning Sessions Chair: Brad Benson
+
'''Morning Sessions Chair: Brad Benson'''
  
 
'''08:30 Welcome and Spokesperson Update'''
 
'''08:30 Welcome and Spokesperson Update'''
* '''08:30''' FNAL Welcome (Lockyer) and Meeting Logistics (Benson) [[Media:2019_03_CMBS4_Fermilab_Welcome.pdf]]
+
* '''08:30''' FNAL Welcome (Nigel Lockyer) and Meeting Logistics (Brad Benson) [[Media:2019_03_CMBS4_Fermilab_Welcome.pdf]]
* '''08:45''' Spokesperson and Project update (Borrill, Carlstrom)
+
* '''08:45''' Spokesperson update (Julian Borrill, John Carlstrom) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1Hjsw0zmFjQRpRM52sC1lbfgH1FfZV1ntN9Bp_ofR9zE Slides]
* '''09:15''' Agency update (Baden)
+
* '''09:15''' Agency update (Drew Baden, Nigel Sharp)
  
 
'''09:30 Collaboration Update '''
 
'''09:30 Collaboration Update '''
* '''09:30''' Governing Board (Halverson)
+
* '''09:30''' Governing Board (Nils Halverson) [[Media:CMB-S4_GB_Activities_Fermilab_Meeting_2019-03-12.pdf]]
* '''09:45''' Membership (Ruhl) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1_OzqTXBoGqSZn2BYjpDAt0gx6ZLfKaxGyr0wa4Q9w24/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
+
* '''09:45''' Membership (John Ruhl) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1_OzqTXBoGqSZn2BYjpDAt0gx6ZLfKaxGyr0wa4Q9w24/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
* '''10:00''' - Publication and Speakers (Huffenberger) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gt12BffbFeRXJL9J9h7bX7_Pf8jLi3Erry2MSxCVpyk/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
+
* '''10:00''' - Publication and Speakers (Kevin Huffenberger) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gt12BffbFeRXJL9J9h7bX7_Pf8jLi3Erry2MSxCVpyk/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
  
 
'''10:15''' ''Coffee Break''
 
'''10:15''' ''Coffee Break''
  
 
'''10:45''' DSR Review and Science'''
 
'''10:45''' DSR Review and Science'''
* '''10:45''' Summary of DSR review and planned response (Julian)
+
* '''10:45''' Summary of DSR review and planned response (Julian Borrill) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1vgqQwN9Q54XiBUzB42H2Hlq6cE7BO6UGLnKGc-z70N0 Slides]
* '''11:05''' r (Pryke)
+
* '''11:05''' r (Clem Pryke) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/18UsMRhIHlk8mrWkIuoSwpLPfTPXZbwceW0EhQ4ixGQ8 Slides]
* '''11:15''' Neff (Meyers)
+
* '''11:15''' Neff (Joel Meyers) [[Media:Light_Relics_Fermilab_2019.pdf]]
* '''11:25''' Mass mapping (Bleem) [https://cmb-s4.org/wiki/images/Mass_mapping_31919_v1.pdf |slides]
+
* '''11:25''' Mass mapping (Lindsey Bleem) [https://cmb-s4.org/wiki/images/Mass_mapping_31919_v1.pdf Slides]
* '''11:35''' Gas mapping (Battaglia)
+
* '''11:35''' Gas mapping (Nick Battaglia) [[Media:CMBS4GasMappingFNAL19.pdf]]
* '''11:45''' Transients (Whitehorn)
+
* '''11:45''' Transients (Nathan Whitehorn) [[Media:CMBS4TransientsFNAL19.pdf]]
* '''11:55''' Science case to measurements requirrements (Holder)
+
* '''11:55''' Science case to measurements requirements (Gil Holder) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1bRtYR_Od-lI_xwKaR5RKCabj6jCCt-3zV8XkFkQIkBs/edit?usp=sharing Slides][https://drive.google.com/open?id=1HPBnf098ErUUdqQjXpCddColre0iHXhP pdf]
* '''12:15''' Measurement requirements to technical requirements  (McMahon)
+
* '''12:15''' Measurement requirements to technical requirements  (Jeff McMahon) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1w60FJp0fabUBF_OLFIbEaDntlPBx7K3DeDq_0GfGTZo/edit#slide=id.g51c952aeca_1_28 Slides]
  
 
'''12:30 Lunch & JSAC (Junior Scientist) Event'''
 
'''12:30 Lunch & JSAC (Junior Scientist) Event'''
Line 69: Line 67:
 
* Junior Scientist Event - register here: https://goo.gl/forms/wdQ0wl5hEh2cLUVl1  
 
* Junior Scientist Event - register here: https://goo.gl/forms/wdQ0wl5hEh2cLUVl1  
  
'''1:30 DSR Reference Design  (Chair Abby Vieregg)'''
+
'''Afternoon Sessions Chair: Abby Vieregg'''
* '''1:30''' Reference design overview (Padin)
 
* '''1:50''' SATs (Kovac)
 
* '''2:05''' LATs (Niemack)
 
* '''2:20''' Detectors and readout (Chang)
 
* '''2:35''' SItes and Integration & commissioning (Benson)
 
* '''2:50''' SAT siting decision tree (Ruhl)
 
* '''3:10''' Budget and schedule (Brenna)
 
  
 +
'''1:30 DSR Reference Design'''
 +
* '''1:30''' Reference design overview (Steve Padin) [[Media:CMBS4RefDesignOverview.pdf]]
 +
* '''1:50''' SATs (John Kovac) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1pLFNJIJPVincoF-KPp2jQBPfDkcxcgY9SQAoGyPXgAI/edit#slide=id.p1 Slides]
 +
* '''2:05''' LATs (Mike Niemack) [[Media:LATs_20190313.pdf]]
 +
* '''2:20''' Detectors and readout (Clarence Chang) [[Media:CMB-S4_FNAL_DSR_DR.pdf]]
 +
* '''2:35''' SItes and Integration & commissioning (Brad Benson, Sara Simon) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gIkb_21oy1SM__cBeLmZmZnlhNUzowRRV6h8TJu3m08/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
 +
* '''2:50''' SAT siting decision tree (John Ruhl) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1NL06LQ2te-bo3LF350T9Lf2D8lTcWqV_AVqjGNqB-Sk/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
 +
* '''3:10''' Budget and schedule (Brenna Flaugher) [[Media:BF-March-Collab-schedule-slides-1.pdf]]
 
'''3:30''' ''Coffee Break''
 
'''3:30''' ''Coffee Break''
  
'''4:00 NSF MSRI Proposals (Chair Abby Vieregg)'''
+
'''4:00 NSF MSRI Proposals'''
* '''4:00''' CMB-S4 MSRI-1 (5+5) (Carlstrom)  
+
* '''4:00''' CMB-S4 MSRI-1 (5+5) (John Carlstrom) [[Media:MSRI-R1-Carlstrom.pdf]]
* '''4:10''' SO MSRI-1 (5+5) (Arnold)
+
* '''4:10''' SO MSRI-1 (5+5) (Mark Devlin/Kam Arnold) [[Media:MSRI1-for-S4.pdf]]
* '''4:20''' SPO MSRI-1 (5+5) (Kovac)   
+
* '''4:20''' SPO MSRI-1 (5+5) (John Kovac)  [[Media:SPO_MSRI_scope_LNAL_Mar2019.pdf]]
* '''4:30''' CCAT-prime MSRI-1 (5+5) (Niemack)  
+
* '''4:30''' CCAT-prime MSRI-1 (5+5) (Mike Niemack) [[Media:CCATprime_CMBS4_20190313r.pdf]]
  
'''4:40 Fireslides (Chair: Sasha Rahlin'''
+
'''4:40 Fireslides (Chair: Sasha Rahlin) [[Media:fireslides.pdf]]'''
  
'''5:30 Poster Session at Wilson Hall'''
+
'''5:30 Group photo at Wilson Hall'''
  
'''5:45 Group photo at Wilson Hall'''
+
'''5:45 Poster Session at Wilson Hall'''
  
 
'''6:00-8:00 Social event and food at Wilson Hall'''
 
'''6:00-8:00 Social event and food at Wilson Hall'''
Line 99: Line 98:
  
 
'''08:30 Path to CD-1 / PDR'''
 
'''08:30 Path to CD-1 / PDR'''
* '''8:30''' Path to CD-1 / PDR (Carlstrom, Borrill)
+
* '''8:30''' Path to CD-1 / PDR (John Carlstrom, Julian Borrill)[[Media:Path_To_CD-1_PDR.pdf]]
* '''9:15''' Project Perspectives (Lawrence)
+
**                Reference Material: [[File:DOE_Order_413-3B.pdf]]
 +
**                Reference Material: [[File:LargeFacilitiesManual_nsf17066.pdf]]
 +
**                Reference Material: [[File:CMB-S4_DesignDecisionPrinciples-v190228.pdf]]
 +
* '''9:15''' Project Perspectives (Charles Lawrence) [[Media:TheProjectPerspective.pdf]]
 
* '''9:30''' Questions and Discussion
 
* '''9:30''' Questions and Discussion
  
 
'''10:00''' ''Coffee Break''
 
'''10:00''' ''Coffee Break''
  
* '''10:30''' Interactive Session: Path to Baseline Design (Chairs: McMahon, Vieregg)
+
* '''10:30''' Interactive Session: Path to Baseline Design (Chairs: Jeff McMahon, Abigail Vieregg) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1P2AsQkPJPP_2y6clK11aPDemBu0jRV4cyYtfQlQ4edo/edit#slide=id.g51c90b7fcc_0_0 Slides], [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1OOaYpTe9e4XSfV3fMlobDwlTSsLOnQkVJQ7imFTwhP8 DM Slides]
 +
** [https://docs.google.com/document/d/1m1gj34O_8ve9GJ2i1oaYAyAD-N18TzNaCIQ0S3H0z9M/edit Notes]
 
** Working group leads present timeline for decision making  
 
** Working group leads present timeline for decision making  
 
** Collated current list of R&D priorities (Technical Coordinators)
 
** Collated current list of R&D priorities (Technical Coordinators)
** Discuss list of R&D items that funding was requested from DOE in February (Brenna)
+
** Discuss list of R&D items that funding was requested from DOE in February (Brenna Flaugher) [[Media:BF-March-Collab-R&D.pdf]]
  
 
'''12:30 Lunch'''
 
'''12:30 Lunch'''
  
 
'''1:30 Submitted Talks  (Chair: Adam Anderson)'''
 
'''1:30 Submitted Talks  (Chair: Adam Anderson)'''
* '''1:30''' Modulations of the CMB (Grin)
+
*'''1:30''' Modulations of the CMB (Daniel Grin)[[File:S4_modulation_2019_grin.pdf]]
* '''1:50''' Non-Gaussian information in the small-scale CMB: from lensing to galaxy velocities (Ferraro)
+
* '''1:50''' Non-Gaussian information in the small-scale CMB (Simone Ferraro) [[Media:ferraro_s4_fermilab.pdf]]
* '''2:10''' CMB-S4 Delensing (Marius)
+
* '''2:10''' CMB-S4 Delensing (Marius Milea)[[File:Millea_cmbs4_fermilab_2019.pdf]]
* '''2:30''' Update on uMUX R&D towards CMB-S4 (Ahmed)
+
* '''2:30''' [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/152CCEt6_pyk2fHw8NZSZHqWKWyPaYwBsx0piJ8njepc/edit?usp=sharing Update on uMUX R&D towards CMB-S4] (Zeesh Ahmed)
* '''2:50''' Recent Advances in Next-Generation Frequency-Multiplexed TES readout (de Haan)  
+
* '''2:50''' Recent Advances in Next-Generation Frequency-Multiplexed TES readout (Tijmen de Haan) [[File:TdH_CMBS4_fMux.pdf]]
* '''3:10''' Inflation constraints from POLARBEAR-1 using a continuously rotating half-wave plate (Goeckner-Wald)
+
* '''3:10''' Demonstration of the low-l performance and control of systematic errors for Polarbear-1 (Neil Goeckner-Wald) [[Media:S4_March_Polarbear.pdf]]
  
 
'''3:30''' ''Coffee Break''
 
'''3:30''' ''Coffee Break''
  
* '''4:00''' Update on European coordination for ground-based CMB experiments (Baccigalupi)
+
* '''4:00''' Update on European coordination for ground-based CMB experiments (Carlo Baccigalupi) [[Media:European_Coordination_for_Ground_Based_CMB_Experiments.pdf]]
  
'''4:30''' ''Collaboration Wrap-up (Spokespeople)''
+
'''4:30''' ''Collaboration Wrap-up (Spokespeople)'' [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/192gZmZHeYwnmwAmbnxmCV84d8_qAA5Zg-gsfa6w1C0c Slides]
  
 
----
 
----
Line 131: Line 134:
  
 
'''8:30 Project Day'''
 
'''8:30 Project Day'''
* '''8:30''' Integrated project plan (Yeck)
+
* '''8:30''' Integrated project plan (Jim Yeck) [[Media: CMB-S4 Integrated Project Plan.pdf]]
* '''9:00''' Preparations for DOE/CD-1 and NSF PDR (Reichanadter)
+
* '''9:00''' Preparations for DOE/CD-1 and NSF PDR (Mark Reichanadter) [[Media: CMB-S4 FNAL Collaboration Meeting-reich_mar19-r1.pdf]]
* '''9:30'''  Critical path, technical decision timeline, design reviews (Flaugher)
+
* '''9:30'''  Critical path, technical decision timeline, design reviews (Brenna Flaugher) [[Media: BF-March-Collab-decisions-reviews.ppt]] [[Media:CMB-S4 Document Management.ppt]]
* '''10:00''' Cost, schedule, contingency overview (Bailey)
+
* '''10:00''' Cost, schedule, contingency overview (Kathy Bailey) [[Media:PM Controls _Fermi.ppt]]
  
 
'''10:30''' ''Coffee Break''
 
'''10:30''' ''Coffee Break''
  
* '''10:45''' preliminary Project Execution Plan (pPEP) Session (Yeck)
+
* '''10:45''' preliminary Project Execution Plan (pPEP) Session (Jim Yeck) [[Media: CMB-S4 Project Execution Plan.ppt]]
** '''11:00'''  pPEP Project Governance & Project Office (Yeck)
+
** '''11:00'''  pPEP Project Governance & Project Office (Jim Yeck)
** '''11:15''' pPEP Agency Scope & Responsibilities (Yeck)
+
** '''11:15''' pPEP Agency Scope & Responsibilities (Jim Yeck)
** '''11:30''' Institutional Roles (Yeck)
+
** '''11:30''' Institutional Roles (Jim Yeck)
* '''11:45''' Systems engineering and risk status (Ahmed, Kurita)
+
* '''11:45''' [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1dnN2NFYj5XQQj28sBMXG-H92SwjAgzJjHmJvvdNN7VY/edit?usp=sharing Systems engineering and risk status] (Zeesh Ahmed, Nadine Kurita)
  
'''12:15''' '''Lunch and Sidet Tours'''
+
'''12:15''' '''Lunch and Sidet Tours''' (map: [[File:Sidet_map.pdf]])
  
 
'''1:30'''  
 
'''1:30'''  
* '''1:30''' R&D plan and priorities (Flaugher)
+
* '''1:30''' R&D plan and priorities (Brenna Flaugher) [[Media:BF-March-Collab-R&D-Plans.pdf]]
* '''2:00'''  Interm Integrated project office (Yeck)
+
* '''2:00'''  Interm Integrated project office (JIm Yeck)
* '''2:15'''  Technical coordination plans (McMahon, Vieregg)
+
* '''2:15'''  Technical coordination plans (Jeff McMahon, Abigail Vieregg) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1c-xDBgC0PnFIdvSFclI7B0s4CrUyAj5bFqIqS6B9Bp4/edit#slide=id.g52a79b362a_0_46 Slides]
* '''2:45'''  In-kind contributions (Borrill)
+
* '''2:45'''  In-kind contributions (Julian Borrill) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1JTmUBh2J_lpLqS9XQ4g8WBR_e7UGnMKlmPqnm2TAabI Slides]
* '''3:00'''  Detectors and readout  - Discussion of next steps
+
* '''3:00'''  Detectors and readout  - Discussion of next steps [[Media:CMB-S4 Task Force Update - FNAL mar19-r3.ppt]]
* '''3:15'''  Site infrastructure - Discussion of critical path and next steps (Brad)
+
* '''3:15'''  Site infrastructure - Discussion of critical path and next steps (Brad Benson) [https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1GY2BdorvZoQMrcdlFrIpwkKiPQ5oojifKupPtnOqdyw/edit?usp=sharing Slides]
  
 
* '''3:45''' Project wrap-up
 
* '''3:45''' Project wrap-up
  
 
'''17:00''' End of meeting
 
'''17:00''' End of meeting

Latest revision as of 15:03, 15 March 2019

Workshop overview

The Fermilab workshop continues a successful series of meetings bringing together the CMB experimental and theoretical community to plan a coordinated, stage-4 ground-based CMB experiment.

The meeting will be held at Fermilab, March 13-15, 2019. The first 2 days will be a collaboration meeting and the 3rd will be our first project meeting; everyone is welcome to all 3 days.

Meeting Info & Registration

Official Workshop Website: Registration, Participants, Hotels, Logistics.

Location: IARC Building at Fermilab http://iarc.fnal.gov/

Remote Connection Information:

Zoom link: https://fnal.zoom.us/j/356003665

One tap mobile:
+16465588656,,356003665# US (New York)
+16699006833,,356003665# US (San Jose)

Dial by your location: +1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose)
Meeting ID: 356 003 665
Find your local number: https://zoom.us/u/acu5oQsITY

Slack channel #fermilab2019 on the CMB-S4 workspace, or use https://cmb-s4.slack.com/messages/CCMNTUDC1

About This Wiki

As for previous workshops, we will use this wiki to organize the sessions, to capture the input from them, and to develop next steps. Participants are encouraged to edit the wiki directly, including uploading plots or a few slides.

Hints for formatting this wiki can be found here


Agenda

Wednesday March 13th

Morning Sessions Chair: Brad Benson

08:30 Welcome and Spokesperson Update

09:30 Collaboration Update

10:15 Coffee Break

10:45 DSR Review and Science

12:30 Lunch & JSAC (Junior Scientist) Event

Afternoon Sessions Chair: Abby Vieregg

1:30 DSR Reference Design

3:30 Coffee Break

4:00 NSF MSRI Proposals

4:40 Fireslides (Chair: Sasha Rahlin) Media:fireslides.pdf

5:30 Group photo at Wilson Hall

5:45 Poster Session at Wilson Hall

6:00-8:00 Social event and food at Wilson Hall


Thursday March 14th

08:30 Path to CD-1 / PDR

10:00 Coffee Break

  • 10:30 Interactive Session: Path to Baseline Design (Chairs: Jeff McMahon, Abigail Vieregg) Slides, DM Slides
    • Notes
    • Working group leads present timeline for decision making
    • Collated current list of R&D priorities (Technical Coordinators)
    • Discuss list of R&D items that funding was requested from DOE in February (Brenna Flaugher) Media:BF-March-Collab-R&D.pdf

12:30 Lunch

1:30 Submitted Talks (Chair: Adam Anderson)

3:30 Coffee Break

4:30 Collaboration Wrap-up (Spokespeople) Slides


Friday March 15th

8:30 Project Day

10:30 Coffee Break

12:15 Lunch and Sidet Tours (map: File:Sidet map.pdf)

1:30

  • 3:45 Project wrap-up

17:00 End of meeting